Winter Tires vs All-Season vs All-Weather: What You Need to Know

Not sure if you need winter, all-season, or all-weather tires? Here’s a breakdown to help you choose what’s right for your vehicle, your climate, and your budget.

When the temperature drops, tire performance changes. But which tire type is right for you — winter, all-season, or all-weather?

Let’s break it down so you can make a confident (and budget-smart) choice.

All-Season Tires: Good in Mild Conditions

Best for: Spring, summer, and fall driving

Limitations: Tread gets stiff under 7°C, reducing traction on ice or snow

Ideal for: Drivers in milder climates with little snow or ice

Winter Tires: Made for the Cold

Best for: Snow, slush, black ice, and freezing temperatures

Features: Softer rubber, deeper tread, and biting edges

Limitations: Wears faster in warm weather

Ideal for: Anyone driving in harsh Canadian winters

All-Weather Tires: A Year-Round Hybrid

Best for: Drivers who want one tire for all seasons

Features: Winter-certified (mountain/snowflake logo), but safe year-round

Ideal for: People in cities or moderate climates who want to skip seasonal changeovers

What Should You Choose?

Ask yourself:

Do you get a lot of snow or ice? Go winter.

Do you drive in a mild region? All-weather could work year-round.

Do you want maximum life and safety? Combine all-seasons for warm months and winters for the cold.

Save on Any Type with Tire Club

No matter which type you choose, Tire Club gives you wholesale access to major brands — saving you up to 50% compared to retail prices.

Need help choosing the right tire? Compare your options here

Shopping Cart